The Pre-Show Pencil Case: Why Trixie Fans Draft Setlists Before the Doors Open
Photo: Justin Higuchi, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
There is a very specific sound that happens outside a Trixie show about forty minutes before doors: the rustle of a folded piece of paper being pulled out of a jacket pocket. Someone uncaps a pen. Someone else says, 'Okay, but if she opens with that, I will actually scream.' And just like that, the pre-show ritual begins.
The setlist guess sheet is not official. It is not sanctioned. It is not going to be collected by venue staff or graded by anyone with actual authority. That is exactly why Trixie fans love it. It turns the waiting into a game, the group chat into a draft room, and the walk to your seat into a rolling debate about deep cuts, crowd favorites, and which song deserves the encore spot.
In 2026, the guess sheet has become its own little backstage tradition—less about nailing the exact order and more about saying, out loud, what you hope the night will become.
The Sheet Is a Social Contract
A good guess sheet is not just a list. It is an invitation. You write down three songs you feel certain about, two you think are plausible, and one you are putting on the paper purely because your heart needs it. Then you hand the pen to the person next to you and say, 'Your turn.'
That exchange is the whole point. Maybe you are in line with strangers who have been trading tour stories for twenty minutes. Maybe you are at a diner table before the show, splitting fries and pretending your picks are based on logic rather than vibes. Maybe you are in the group chat, where someone has already built a spreadsheet and someone else has responded with a single eye-roll emoji. Either way, the sheet gives everyone a job: take a guess, make a case, and brace for the moment the first chord proves you brilliantly right or hilariously wrong.
It also keeps the conversation from turning into a spoiler trap. More on that in a minute.
Build a Guess Sheet That Plays Nice
You do not need fancy stationery. A napkin works. The back of a receipt works. A notes app works until someone asks to see your picks and you have to hand over your phone with three unread texts and a screenshot of a grocery list. But if you want the full ritual, a printable template is a nice touch. Here is the one we keep passing around:
| Slot | Song Title | Why I Think It's In | Confidence (1–5) | Deep Cut? | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lock #1 | Y / N | ||||
| Lock #2 | Y / N | ||||
| Lock #3 | Y / N | ||||
| Wildcard #1 | Y / N | ||||
| Wildcard #2 | Y / N | ||||
| Heart's Choice | Y / N | ||||
| Encore Guess | Y / N |
The rules are loose, but the etiquette is real. Keep your confidence rankings honest. Do not put every song at a five just because you are feeling brave. And if someone picks a deep cut you have never heard live, do not laugh—ask them why. That is how you end up in a twenty-minute conversation about B-sides, bonus tracks, and the one performance from three cities ago that still lives rent-free in somebody's camera roll.
Spoiler Etiquette for the Group Chat
The guess sheet is fun right up until someone wanders into the chat with a setlist photo from an earlier stop. Then it becomes a crime scene.
The rule is simple: if you are posting about a show that has already happened, give people a warning. Use a spoiler tag. Put a few blank lines before the details. Do not drop the opener into a message with no context and then disappear. And if you are the person who wants to go in completely clean, say so early. Most fans are happy to keep the surprise intact—they just need to know who is playing the no-spoilers game and who is ready to compare notes.
A good group chat has room for both. The spoiler-hungry fans can build their sheets with full knowledge and still argue about order. The clean-run fans can guess from instinct and hope. The only unforgivable move is the drive-by spoiler with no warning, posted at 11:47 p.m. like a raccoon knocking over a trash can.
Superlatives for the Audaciously Wrong
Every guess sheet deserves a tiny awards ceremony. Not for accuracy—accuracy is boring. For audacity.
Most Likely to Cause a Group Chat Civil War: The fan who predicts a song nobody else has mentioned in months. They have a theory. They have evidence. The evidence is a three-second clip from a soundcheck and a feeling in their left elbow.
The Deep Cut That Requires a PowerPoint: A pick so specific that the person defending it starts drawing diagrams on the back of the sheet. Respect.
Best Fake-Out: The prediction that gets one line right and then swerves into a completely different song. Somehow, the person still claims partial credit.
Most Confident Wrong Answer: A five-out-of-five lock that does not appear. The paper is folded. The pen is capped. The dignity is gone.
Most Likely to Be Right by Accident: The friend who writes down a song because they like it, not because they have any tour knowledge, and then watches the room lose its mind when it actually happens.
The Best Kind of Wrong
The guess sheet does not need to be accurate to work. It needs to get people talking. It needs to give the waiting period a shape. It needs to turn a bunch of separate fans into a temporary committee with one shared goal: make the next hour feel like it belongs to us.
And when the lights finally go down, the sheet goes back in the pocket. Maybe you got one. Maybe you got none. Maybe you got the encore and had to quietly text your group chat a string of exclamation points while pretending to be cool. Either way, you did the ritual. You made a guess. You joined the conversation.
That is the real backstage pass—the paper you fold in half, the pen you borrow, and the friend who says, 'Okay, but hear me out.'